by Elizabeth Weise, USA TODAY
A government report expected to be released Wednesday finds that
the Environmental Protection Agency is severely hampered by laws
that make it difficult and expensive for the agency to do its
job assessing the health risks of chemicals.
The report from the General Accountability Office (GAO) comes
as new research increasingly shows that exposure to even tiny
amounts of some widely used chemicals can be harmful to developing
fetuses.
As better scientific information becomes available, countries
are beginning to overhaul their regulatory policies for toxics.
The process is beginning in the USA.
"The vast majority of chemicals used in consumer products
today have never undergone any federal safety review," says
Sen. Jim Jeffords, I-Vt., ranking minority member of the Senate
Environment and Public Works Committee.
To restrict or ban dangerous chemicals under the 1976 Toxic Substances
Control Act, the agency must demonstrate they "pose unreasonable
risks," a standard not well-defined under the law.
But because of a court ruling requiring that EPA do costs-benefits
balancing for every possible regulatory approach, those findings
are almost impossible to make and it's now extremely difficult
to ban chemicals, says Lisa Heinzerling, a Georgetown University
law professor and expert on environmental law.
"I think it's fair to say they couldn't be completed in
my lifetime," she says.
Charles Auer, director of EPA's Office of Pollution Prevention
and Toxics, says aspects of TSCA "have proven challenging"
but that the law "provides EPA with authority adequate to
protect human health and the environment from unreasonable risks."
To strengthen EPA, the report says Congress should:
• Give EPA explicit legal authority to force companies
to test chemicals for toxicity.
• Authorize EPA to share information about potentially
toxic chemicals with states and other countries, difficult now
because more than 60% of the information submitted for new chemicals
is declared confidential business information.
Sens. Jeffords and Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., plan to announce
legislation today to overhaul the rules that govern the EPA.
The chemical industry counters that current voluntary EPA-industry
programs show that together they protect the public, says Chris
VandenHeuvel of industry group American Chemistry Council.