by IRIN
MULTAN - Last month, Saira, six, died in Jehanian,
a village near Multan in the southern Pakistani province of Punjab.
The area is best known for its high quality mangoes and for its
cotton, the country's most important cash crop.
Doctors in the village seem uncertain over what caused the child's
death – but her grief-stricken parents are sure. "It
was the chemicals in the pesticides. She came with me sometimes
to work in the fields, and those chemicals killed her," said
Saira's father, Anwar.
Anwar and his wife Uzma, like many other parents across Punjab,
believe the worsening health of many children is caused by pesticides
and their widespread misuse.
While the arrival of modern pesticides has revolutionised agriculture,
boosting production many times over and making it possible to
feed a growing population, the health impact of the chemicals
is a source of growing concern.
According to the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) Regional
Office for Asia-Pacific in the Thai capital, Bangkok, every year
chemical pesticides worth some US $2.5 billion are sold in countries
in the region.
Many of these pesticides – such as DDT, chlordane and heptachlor
– which are regularly imported by countries in Asia, are
banned or restricted in the countries of manufacture for health
and environmental safety reasons.
Since 1994, the FAO has been running a programme to raise awareness
about such pesticides, with Pakistan among the targeted countries.
Studies conducted in Indian Punjab, just across the border, including
one carried out in 2003 by the international environmental pressure
group, Greenpeace, titled 'Arrested Development', linked pesticide
use to high rates of childhood cancers, respiratory problems,
mental development problems and other diseases.
Many identical pesticides are used in Pakistan. Doctors who treated
little Saira believe she may have suffered blood cancer, but maintain
they do not have the diagnostic facilities necessary to reach
a definite verdict.
Doctors at Multan's Nishtar hospital, the largest facility in
southern Punjab, said: "There is a definite increase in children,
and also adults, suffering illnesses apparently linked to exposure
to dangerous chemicals from pesticides."
Evidence from across the country suggests that farm workers who
ingest pesticide toxins while spraying them on crops or working
in fields are facing growing ill health. Pesticide residues have
also been found in the human food chain, threatening consumers.
Misuse of pesticides, including highly toxic pesticides meant
for crops such as cotton being used on food crops, and the failure
of agricultural workers to adopt safety measures, such as wearing
masks while spraying fields – either due to a lack of awareness
or the lack of availability of such items - are all factors contributing
to the increase in health problems.
"You can taste the chemicals when you bite into an apple
or a guava. It tastes like chlorine. These toxins are obviously
present in the fruit, and even mangoes are not natural now, as
they were when we were kids," said Sultan Mahmood, a manager
of a Multan grocery shop.
Chemicals used to artificially ripen fruits such as mangoes are
also blamed for the poisons many believe are present in the fruit,
which can be seen on some products as a whitish residue on the
surface.
An April 2005 study published in the Pakistan Medical Sciences
Journal reported that out of a total of 578 patients admitted
to Nishtar hospital between 1996 and 2000 with chemical poisoning,
about 64 percent were victims of organic pesticide poisoning.
Of these around 73 percent were males and 27 percent females.
In another study by Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and
Research (PILER), Dr Tariq Awan, who compiled the survey, found
that in the southern Punjab and Sindh provinces during the cotton-picking
season, many women reported a variety of diseases not seen at
other times of the year – pesticides were suggested as the
cause.
Research on the issue is limited, observers say. "In the
first place, interest in the whole subject area is limited. Secondly,
as far as conducting a study is concerned, the multinationals
marketing their products in the country actively discourage it,
and they have a huge lobby," environmental scientist, Dr
Farooq Pervaiz, said.
However, public awareness in Pakistan is growing, particularly
after reports last year that sub-soil water in the Lahore area
contained high levels of potentially lethal arsenic, due to the
leaching of residue from pesticides and fertilisers.
As a consequence, organic farming is growing in popularity in
Punjab province. Rafiq Ahmed, who manages an organic food shop
in Lahore explained: "The demand is growing by the day. Sometimes
we just can't keep up with it."
But growing crops organically is complicated and fraught with
problems. "Pesticides are in such heavy use that the insects
invade any area where they are not in use and thus destroy crops
grown without pesticides in days," said Samina Qamar, who
has tried her hand at growing organic wheat to sell at her farm
on the outskirts of Lahore.
The government accepts pesticide use needs more careful regulation.
"The age of pesticides is here to stay. We can't manage without
them, so we need to see how to use them properly. We are willing
to conduct research on this," Punjab agriculture minister,
Arshad Khan Lodhi, said.
Other semi-autonomous organisations, such as the Pakistan Poverty
Alleviation Fund (PPAF), based in the capital, Islamabad, have
also been working on ways to tackle the pesticide menace. "We
believe it is useful to explore indigenous herbs that can be made
to produce safe pesticides," a spokesman at the organisation
said.